• July 18, 2024, 10:35 pm

Facebook watches teens online as they prep for college SoftAIT

Reporter Name 276 Time View
Update : Friday, December 1, 2023

[ad_1]

This article was originally published on The Markup

Picture a high school student who wants to go to college, likes to cheer on her school’s football team, and plays in a sport or two herself. 

One day after school, she signs up for an official ACT account so she can schedule her college entrance exam and see what score she gets after taking it. Then, she researches a few colleges through the Common App’s website, and like more than a million students every year, she uses the site to start an application for her dream college. 

She spends a few minutes starting a presentation for class using the website Prezi. On a homework break, she registers for her high school’s after-school sports program through a service called ArbiterSports, then she hops on her phone, remembering to order a yearbook through the company Jostens. Long day over, she takes out her laptop and flips on her school’s big football game through the NFHS Network, a subscription service for high school sports.

Here’s what the student doesn’t know: Although she surfed the internet in the privacy of her home, Facebook saw much of what she did.

Every single site she visited used the Meta Pixel, a tracking tool that silently collects and transmits information to Facebook as users browse the web, according to testing by The Markup. Millions of invisible pixels are embedded on websites across the internet, allowing businesses and organizations to target their customers on Facebook with ads. 

Businesses embed the pixel on their own websites voluntarily, to gather enough information on their customers so they can advertise to them later on Meta’s social platforms, Facebook and Instagram. If there’s a pixel on a website’s checkout page and a visitor buys a baseball hat with their school’s logo, for example, the pixel may note that interaction, and the owner of that page can send that person more apparel ads on Facebook later. This is one of the reasons people see the same ad following them on Facebook and Instagram after they shopped on a different site. The Markup has also found hospitalstelehealth companiestax filing websites, and mental health crisis websites using the pixel, and transmitting sensitive information to social media companies.

Along with encouraging businesses to spend ad dollars, Facebook also receives the transmitted data, and can use it to hone its algorithms. Facebook can also use data from the pixel to link website visitors to their Facebook accounts, meaning businesses can reach the exact people who visited their sites. The pixel collects data regardless of whether the visitor has an account. 

Our investigation found the pixel on dozens of popular websites targeting kids from kindergarten to college, including sites that students are all but required to use if they want to participate in school activities or apply to college.

See our data here: GitHub

On some level, that’s not a surprise: tracking tools like the pixel are so widespread that intensive tracking is almost the status quo. You could make the argument that these educational sites are “just the same as any other site,” said Marshini Chetty, associate professor of computer science at the University of Chicago.

But dealing with kids raises bigger questions about tracking on the web. “Why is there the Meta Pixel? Why are there session recorders?” she said. “What is the place of that on these sites?”

In 2022, around 1.4 million high school seniors took the ACT, up from 1.3 million in 2021, according to the nonprofit that runs the test. The Markup found that the official ACT sign-in page tracked users who visited the site, and when a student logged in, the pixel sent Facebook a scrambled version of the student’s email address. Meta says these “hashed” email addresses “help protect user privacy.” But it’s simple to determine the pre-obfuscated version of the data—and Meta explicitly uses the hashed information to link other pixel data to Facebook and Instagram profiles. 

After signing into their ACT account, if a student accepted cookies on the following page, Facebook received details on almost everything they clicked on—including scrambled but identifiable data like their first and last name, and whether they’re registering for the ACT. The site even registered clicks about a student’s ethnicity and gender, and whether they planned to request college financial aid or needed accommodations for a disability.

An ACT spokesperson declined to comment, but a few days after The Markup reached out for comment, we tested the ACT account page for the pixel again, and found that it was no longer sending personal data to Facebook.

When students visit the Common App website, a pixel tells Facebook what they click, including whether they start an application. The associated application URL they’re directed to after doesn’t track them. More than 1 million students use the Common App to apply to colleges, according to the organization, and more than 1,000 colleges accept applications through the platform. The organization did not respond to a request for comment.

If someone starts or modifies a presentation on Prezi, Facebook gets notified. When a student or parent visits ArbiterSports to sign up for activities at their high school or college, the pixel tells Facebook what schools they searched for on the platform. When a person clicks an email address to reach out to a school for more information, the pixel tells Facebook. According to ArbiterSports’ website, the company claims to be “the backbone of K-12 and collegiate sports and event management in America” and that it’s used by “over 65 million Americans, one in every 5 of us.” Prezi and ArbiterSports didn’t respond to requests for comment. 

Jostens tracks anyone looking for a yearbook in detail, telling Facebook what schools they browsed for, and sends along their hashed email address when they log in. And if a visitor navigates to a high school sports page through the NFHS network to watch a game, the site sends the text of that search to Facebook. Jostens says it partners with more than 40,000 schools and serves 2.5 million customers annually. Some schools require students to place an order with Jostens for apparel like graduation gowns. Jostens didn’t respond to a request for comment.

While many of these sites did not send along a student’s (or any website visitor’s) email or name, Facebook doesn’t need that information in order to track and retarget them for ads. Data from the pixel is connected to individual IP addresses—an identifier that’s like a computer’s mailing address and can generally be linked to a specific individual or household—creating a much more intimate connection between students and their page views. (Meta offers options on the pixel to let organizations adjust what data they collect and transmit—and here’s how you can turn it off or limit it.)

A Meta spokesperson, Emil Vazquez, noted in an emailed statement that the company has recently made changes to how advertisers can market to teens on its services, including limiting the ways advertisers can target them. The company’s terms of use for its business tools prohibit organizations from sending data on children under 13.

“We’ve been clear in our policies that advertisers should not send sensitive information about people through our Business Tools,” Vazquez said. “Doing so is against our policies and we educate advertisers on properly setting up Business tools to prevent this from occurring. Our system is designed to filter out potentially sensitive data it is able to detect.”

Tracking kids under 13

Facebook doesn’t allow children under 13 to use its services. But The Markup found that some sites directed at kids under 13 used the pixel to track visitors as well. 

If a teacher assigned a class to visit the educational reading website Raz-Kids, a service for kids between kindergarten and fifth grade, for example, the site would alert Facebook when visitors clicked a button labeled “KIDS LOGIN.” (There was no pixel on a dedicated log-in page visitors are directed to after that.)

The homepages of ABC Mouse—an animated learning site—and XtraMath—an educational math service—used the tool to track visits to their homepages. The website kids.getepic.com, a digital reading platform for children, didn’t use the pixel. But if a student navigated to the main page, getepic.com, and clicked the “I’m a kid” pop-up, the click and the button text identifying them as a kid was sent to Facebook. The service explicitly markets itself on its site as being for kids 12 years old and younger. 

Once a visitor gets past the homepages of these sites, however, they are no longer tracked, as the sites all have dedicated log-in pages for students that did not use the pixel tracker.

Spokespeople for these sites for kids under 13 stressed that they had separate URLs specifically for kids that did not use the pixel, and only used the pixel on their public-facing homepages to market to potential buyers of their products, like teachers. 

Roy King III, Executive Director of XtraMath.org, said in an email that the site uses the pixel for business campaigns but “student data from our application is not mixed, associated, or identified with any marketing data” and that the site complies with privacy laws for children. Kiki Burger, a spokesperson for Epic, also noted their use of a separate tracking-free site and said Epic’s actual educational product does not track. 

John Jorgenson, a spokesperson for Cambium Learning, parent company of Raz-Kids, similarly pointed out that kids are directed to a page without tracking, saying “our approach is to separate application log-on pages from other parts of our websites with general website traffic, which we do track.”

The Markup tested these sites for the pixel because they were some of the most commonly linked to websites from public schools in the U.S. We gathered data on popular education-related websites by building on a list created by computer science researchers from the University of Chicago and New York University (NYU) this year. The researchers used public databases of K-12 schools to develop a list of URLs for more than 60,000 public schools in the United States, generating more than 15,000 domains from those schools. 

The researchers then scraped those school domains for links to other sites. They gathered a list of the links that appeared most frequently, giving them a list of which websites schools were most likely to direct visitors to. They then whittled the list down to only sites that were related to educational technology. Finally, they used The Markup’s Blacklight tool, which scans websites for trackers, finding widespread use of tools like the Meta Pixel. 

The Markup re-ran the researchers’ Blacklight search, then went further. For 30 websites on the list that used the pixel, we analyzed the network traffic while browsing the site, which gave us detailed insight into how the sites communicated with Facebook.

In all, we searched through dozens of sites on the list that used the Meta Pixel in some way. The search had some limitations: Just because a school linked out to a site didn’t necessarily mean the school approved of it, or wanted students to use it. Many of those sites were also promotional sites for educational products directed toward school administrators, not students. Since they required a login, The Markup couldn’t review some of those products directly.

Jim Siegl, a senior technologist at the Future of Privacy Forum, said school districts might do a great job policing apps they contract with for services and that kids use while in school. But even trying to search for those apps through corporate marketing pages on the open web is a different story.

Siegl uses the analogy of a school in a neighborhood surrounded by a corporation, with surveillance cameras scattered all around. “In order to get to school, Billy has to walk through this corporate neighborhood and through the lobby of the corporation to get to the classroom,” he said.

Facebook’s fraught relationship with kids

Early last year, The Markup launched the Pixel Hunt, a project exploring how the Meta Pixel is quietly used to track web users. The project has highlighted several ways the Meta Pixel collects potentially sensitive data, including educationalfinancial, and health information. Since launch, the series has sparked concern and direct inquiry from legislators and regulators, and led to dozens of lawsuits against Meta and other companies. 

However, there’s been little focus on how pixels on the web may be collecting data on kids and teens. Earlier this year, Gizmodo reported that the College Board, which is responsible for administering the SATs and Advanced Placement exams, was transmitting information on SAT scores and grades to Facebook, as well as TikTok and others. Recent testing by The Markup showed the pixel still active on some SAT-related pages. According to the College Board, 1.9 million students in the class of 2023 took the SAT. Jerome White, director of communications for the College Board, said in a statement the organization doesn’t send personally identifiable information to Meta and that “pixels are simply a means to measure the effectiveness of College Board advertising.”

Facebook’s relationship with young people is especially fraught, and comes with a years-long history of controversy that extends to today. Last month, a coalition of more than 40 states filed suit against Meta. Attorneys general for the states accused Meta of using intentionally addictive design to hook kids and teens on apps like Instagram, and violating children’s privacy in the process. Meta disputes the claims and argues that it has introduced protections for young people.

This month, Arturo Béjar, a former Facebook engineer, testified to Congress that Facebook knew about, and had failed to stop, developing systems that were hurting kids. Béjar wasn’t the first former Meta worker to weigh in on the issue. Another former employee, Frances Haugen, released internal documents in 2021 indicating Facebook knew the company’s products were damaging the mental health of teenage girls, findings that were in line with what independent researchers have said.

Those revelations followed mounting concerns that Facebook has been drawing young children into an unhealthy digital space. Those fears were magnified even further following news that Facebook planned to release a version of Instagram for children under 13 years old, who have special privacy protections in the United States. 

That plan quickly led to scrutiny from lawmakers and children’s health advocates, and in 2021, about six months after news of the project leaked, the company announced that it was halting Instagram Kids. “While we stand by the need to develop this experience, we’ve decided to pause this project,” Instagram Head Adam Mosseri said in a statement at the time. “This will give us time to work with parents, experts, policymakers and regulators, to listen to their concerns, and to demonstrate the value and importance of this project for younger teens online today.”

There’s no federal privacy law in the United States that broadly covers all data. There is one law, passed in 1998, that does cover data for children under 13 years old: the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act, or COPPA.

COPPA applies to sites that are directed or marketed to children under 13, or who know they’re collecting data on kids under 13. Those sites have to get parental permission before collecting data and give those families a chance to opt out, including through web tracking technologies. If not, they could face penalties from the Federal Trade Commission. Rather than face a potentially daunting task of getting parental permission from millions, some services simply don’t allow children under 13 on their platforms—although in practice, of course, many still make accounts anyway by lying about their age. 

What legally counts as a service directed toward kids is open to some interpretation, with the FTC taking enforcement action against diverse companies like educational technology vendor Edmodo and Amazon, for its Alexa devices. The FTC says it might find a service is directed toward kids based on the subject matter, as well as if they feature “the use of animated characters or child-oriented activities and incentives.”

But again, “kids” means under 13. “If you’re over 13, there’s no real specific law that addresses privacy protections,” Siegl said.

In May, the FTC took direct action against Facebook, alleging the company had violated a previous privacy order and banning the company from monetizing any data collected on users under 18. The agency said Facebook’s “recklessness has put young users at risk.” Meta called the action “a political stunt” and said the FTC was stretching its authority.

There are signs that momentum is building for tighter, more expansive regulations for kids. Multiple states have proposed or passed laws that expand the types of data covered or  expanded COPPA’s protections to include kids who are 13 to 18. 

But attempts to pass new federal laws have stalled in the past. One now on the table, the Kids Online Safety Act, would place new requirements on social media sites to prevent minors from seeing harmful content. That bill and others have, however, triggered civil rights concerns over censorship, especially over what content might be “harmful.” 

Meanwhile, the people responsible for protecting students and kids have to make do with what they have.

As part of their research, the University of Chicago and NYU team interviewed school administrators about their security practices. They broadly found that many districts lack the technical skills or resources to properly assess privacy concerns for students. 

“Some sort of comprehensive federal privacy regulation would be helpful,” said Jake Chanenson, a PhD student and law student at the University of Chicago who worked on the research paper identifying educational sites. “The last privacy act we had was in the ‘90s.”

This article was originally published on The Markup and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.



[ad_2]


আপনার মতামত লিখুন :

114 responses to “Facebook watches teens online as they prep for college SoftAIT”

  1. Donaldfep says:

    Профессиональные seo https://seo-optimizaciya-kazan.ru услуги для максимизации онлайн-видимости вашего бизнеса. Наши эксперты проведут глубокий анализ сайта, оптимизируют контент и структуру, улучшат технические аспекты и разработают индивидуальные стратегии продвижения.

  2. Top sports news https://idman-azerbaycan.com.az photos and blogs from experts and famous athletes, as well as statistics and information about matches of leading championships.

  3. OscarTed says:

    The Dota 2 website https://dota2.com.az Azerbaijan provides the most detailed information about the latest game updates, tournaments and upcoming events. We have all the winning tactics, secrets and important guides.

  4. LeroyJurce says:

    Check out the latest news, guides and in-depth reviews of the available options for playing Minecraft Az https://minecraft.com.az. Find the latest information about Minecraft Download, Pocket Edition and Bedrock Edition.

  5. BruceJek says:

    Latest news about games for Android https://android-games.com.az, reviews and daily updates. Read now and get the latest information on the most exciting games

  6. Barrydible says:

    Latest news and analytics of the Premier League https://premier-league.com.az. Detailed descriptions of matches, team statistics and the most interesting football events. EPL Azerbaijan is the best place for football fans.

  7. MatthewJal says:

    1xbet https://1xbet.best-casino-ar.com with withdrawal without commission. Register online in a few clicks. A large selection of slot machines in mobile applications and convenient transfers in just a few minutes.

  8. GeorgeRek says:

    Pin-up Casino https://pin-up.admsov.ru/ is an online casino licensed and regulated by the government of Curacao . Founded in 2016, it is home to some of the industry’s leading providers, including NetEnt, Microgaming, Play’n GO and others. This means that you will be spoiled for choice when it comes to choosing a game.

  9. Pin Up Casino https://pin-up.sibelshield.ru official online casino website for players from the CIS countries. Login and registration to the Pin Up casino website is open to new users with bonuses and promotional free spins.

  10. Jessecow says:

    Открой мир карточных игр в Pin-Up https://pin-up.porsamedlab.ru казино Блэкджек, Баккара, Хило и другие карточные развлечения. Регистрируйтесь и играйте онлайн!

  11. MichaelBiz says:

    Latest Diablo news https://diablo.com.az game descriptions and guides. Diablo.az is the largest Diablo portal in the Azerbaijani language.

  12. Latest World of Warcraft (WOW) tournament news https://wow.com.az, strategies and game analysis. The most detailed gaming portal in Azerbaijani language

  13. RobertBok says:

    Discover exciting virtual football in Fortnite https://fortnite.com.az. Your central hub for the latest news, expert strategies and interesting e-sports reports. Collecting points with us!

  14. Kennethhen says:

    Kevin De Bruyne https://kevin-de-bruyne.liverpool-fr.com Belgian footballer, born 28 June 1991 years in Ghent. He has had a brilliant club career and also plays for the Belgium national team. De Bruyne is known for his spectacular goals and brilliant assists.

  15. GeorgeCor says:

    Mohamed Salah Hamed Mehrez Ghali https://mohamed-salah.liverpool-fr.com Footballeur egyptien, attaquant du club anglais de Liverpool et l’equipe nationale egyptienne. Considere comme l’un des meilleurs joueurs du monde.

  16. BillyDrasp says:

    Paul Pogba https://psg.paul-pogba-fr.com is a world-famous football player who plays as a central midfielder. The player’s career had its share of ups and downs, but he was always distinguished by his perseverance and desire to win.

  17. LucioCew says:

    Изготовление, сборка и ремонт мебели https://shkafy-na-zakaz.blogspot.com для Вас, от эконом до премиум класса.

  18. RobertTah says:

    Forward Rodrigo https://rodrygo.real-madrid-ar.com is now rightfully considered a rising star of Real Madrid. The talented Santos graduate is compared to Neymar and Cristiano Ronaldo, but the young talent does not consider himself a star.

  19. RodolfoVar says:

    Latest news and information about Marcelo https://marcelo.com.az on this site! Find Marcelo’s biography, career, playing stats and more. Find out the latest information about football master Marcelo with us!

  20. Conor Anthony McGregor https://conor-mcgregor.com.az Irish mixed martial arts fighter who also performed in professional boxing. He performs under the auspices of the UFC in the lightweight weight category. Former UFC lightweight and featherweight champion.

  21. Реальные анкеты https://prostitutki-vyzvat-moskva.ru Москвы с проверенными фото – от элитных путан до дешевых шлюх. Каталог всех индивидуалок на каждой станции метро с реальными фотографиями без ретуши и с отзывами реальных клиентов.

  22. AnthonyDef says:

    Совсем недавно открылся новый интернет портал BlackSprut (Блекспрут) https://bs2cite.cc в даркнете, который предлагает купить нелегальные товары и заказать запрещенные услуги. Самая крупнейшая площадка СНГ. Любимые шопы и отзывчивая поддержка.

  23. JerryCes says:

    Diego Armando Maradona https://diego-maradona.com.az Argentine footballer who played as an attacking midfielder and striker. He played for the clubs Argentinos Juniors, Boca Juniors, Barcelona, ??Napoli, and Sevilla.

  24. Brettpon says:

    Lev Ivanovich Yashin https://lev-yashin.com.az Soviet football player, goalkeeper. Olympic champion in 1956 and European champion in 1960, five-time champion of the USSR, three-time winner of the USSR Cup.

  25. Robertgah says:

    Game World https://kz-games.kz offers the latest online gaming news, game reviews, gameplay and ideas, gaming tactics and tips . Start playing our most popular and amazing games and get ready to become the leader in the online gaming world!

  26. Charlesgef says:

    Latest news and information about the NBA https://basketball-kz.kz in Kazakhstan. Hot stories, player transfers and highlights. Watch the NBA world with us.

  27. HarryCic says:

    The latest top football news https://football-kz.kz today. Interviews with football players, online broadcasts and match results, analytics and football forecasts, photos and videos.

  28. ThomasGef says:

    Check out Minecraft kz https://minecraft-kz.kz for the latest news, guides, and in-depth reviews of the game options available. Find the latest information on Minecraft Download, Pocket Edition and Bedrock Edition.

  29. ThomasFah says:

    Доставка груза и грузоперевозки https://tamozhennyy-deklarant.blogspot.com по России через транспортную компанию автотранспортом доступна и для частных лиц. Перевозчик отправит или доставит ваш груз: выгодные тарифы индивидуальный подход из рук в руки 1 машиной.

  30. Зеркала интерьерные https://zerkala-mag.ru в интернет-магазине «Зеркала с подсветкой» Самые низкие цены на зеркала!

  31. The latest top football news https://football.sport-news-eg.com today. Interviews with football players, online broadcasts and match results, analytics and football forecasts, photos and videos.

  32. LewisAluth says:

    Spider-Man https://spiderman.kz the latest news, articles, reviews, dates, spoilers and other latest information. All materials on the topic “Spider-Man”

  33. StaceyRof says:

    Latest Counter-Strike 2 news https://counter-strike-kz.kz, watch the most successful tournaments and be the best in the gaming world.

  34. News and events of the American Basketball League https://basketball-eg.com in Egypt. Hot events, player transfers and the most interesting events. Explore the world of the NBA with us.

  35. FelixAtown says:

    Minecraft news https://minecraft-ar.com, guides and in-depth reviews of the gaming features available in Minecraft Ar. Get the latest information on downloading Minecraft, Pocket Edition and Bedrock Edition.

  36. News, tournaments, guides and strategies about the latest GTA games https://gta-ar.com. Stay tuned for the best GTA gaming experience

  37. Latest news https://android-games-ar.com about Android games, reviews and daily updates. The latest information about the most exciting games.

  38. AaronJasse says:

    Harry Kane’s journey https://bavaria.harry-kane-cz.com from Tottenham’s leading striker to Bayern’s leader and Champions League champion – this is the story of a triumphant ascent to the football Olympus.

  39. RobertTep says:

    Изготовим для Вас изделия из металла https://smith-moskva.blogspot.com, по вашим чертежам или по нашим эскизам.

  40. Полезные советы и пошаговые инструкции по строительству https://syndyk.by, ремонту и дизайну домов и квартир, выбору материалов, монтажу и установке своими руками.

  41. Lionel Messi https://intermiami.lionel-messi-cz.com, one of the best football players of all time, moves to Inter Miami” and changes the face of North American football.

  42. Curtiszes says:

    We explore the path of Luka Modric https://realmadrid.luka-modric-cz.com to Real Madrid, from a difficult adaptation to legendary Champions League triumphs and personal awards.

  43. Anthonyciz says:

    Find out how Pedri https://barcelona.pedri-cz.com becomes a key figure for Barcelona – his development, influence and ambitions determine the club’s future success in world football.

  44. A study of the influence of Rodrigo https://realmadrid.rodrygo-cz.com on the success and marketing strategy of Real Madrid: analysis of technical skills, popularity in Media and commercial success.

  45. JamesBap says:

    Find out how Virgil van Dijk https://liverpool.virgil-van-dijk-cz.com became an integral part of style игры «Liverpool», ensuring the stability and success of the team.

  46. JaimeSeeby says:

    A fascinating story about how David Alaba https://realmadrid.david-alaba-cz.com after starting his career at the Austrian academy Vienna became a key player and leader of the legendary Real Madrid.

  47. Kennethlap says:

    The story of how the incredibly talented footballer Riyad Mahrez https://alahli.riyad-mahrez-cz.com reached new heights in career, moving to Al Ahly and leading the team to victory.

  48. The fascinating story of Marcus Rashford’s ascent https://manchester-united.marcus-rashford-cz.com to glory in the Red Devils: from a young talent to one of the key players of the team.

  49. KeithUnilt says:

    The fascinating story of Antonio Rudiger’s transfer https://real-madrid.antonio-rudiger-cz.com to Real Madrid and his rapid rise as a key player at one of the best clubs in the world.

  50. RobertcaR says:

    Fascinating event related to this Keanu Reeves helped him in the role of the iconic John Wick characters https://john-wick.keanu-reeves.cz, among which there is another talent who has combat smarts with inappropriate charisma.

  51. Try to make a fascinating actor Johnny Depp https://secret-window.johnny-depp.cz, who will become the slave of his strong hero Moudriho Creeps in the thriller “Secret Window”.

  52. Jackie Chan https://peakhour.jackie-chan.cz from a poor boy from Hong Kong to a world famous Hollywood stuntman. The incredible success story of Jackie Chan.

  53. StacyThype says:

    Jon Jones https://ufc.jon-jones.cz a dominant fighter with unrivaled skill, technique and physique who has conquered the light heavyweight division.

  54. The legendary Spanish racer Fernando Alonso https://formula-1.fernando-alonso.cz returns to Formula 1 after several years.

  55. Jamescex says:

    Activision and Call of Duty https://activision.call-of-duty.cz leading video game publisher and iconic shooter with a long history market dominance.

  56. AaronSmony says:

    Latest news and analysis of the English Premier League https://epl-ar.com. Detailed descriptions of matches, team statistics and the most interesting football events.

  57. RobertNat says:

    Free movies https://www.moviesjoy.cc and TV streaming online, watch movies online in HD 1080p.

  58. RosarioGar says:

    The latest analysis, reviews of https://spider-man-ar.com tournaments and the most interesting things from the “Spider-Man” series of games in Azerbaijani language. It’s all here!

  59. EddieDog says:

    NFL https://nfl-ar.com News, analysis and topics about the latest practices, victories and records. A portal that explores the most beautiful games in the NFL world in general.

  60. JamesJak says:

    Discover exciting virtual football https://fortnite-ar.com in Fortnite. Your central hub for the latest news, expert strategy and exciting eSports reporting.

  61. Scotthoach says:

    Discover the wonderful world of online games https://onlayn-oyinlar.com with GameHub. Get the latest news, reviews and tips for your favorite games. Join our gaming community today!

  62. Jameswrada says:

    Explore the extraordinary journey of Kylian Mbappe https://mbappe-real-madrid.com, from his humble beginnings to global stardom.

  63. Официальный сайт онлайн-казино Vavada https://vavada-kz-game.kz это новый адрес лучших слотов и джекпотов. Ознакомьтесь с бонусами и играйте на реальные деньги из Казахстана.

  64. Marcus Lilian Thuram-Julien https://internationale.marcus-thuram-fr.com French footballer, forward for the Internazionale club and French national team.

  65. Manchester City and Erling Haaland https://manchester-city.erling-haaland-fr.com explosive synergy in action. How a club and a footballer light up stadiums with their dynamic play.

  66. WarrenBiz says:

    Lionel Messi https://inter-miami.lionel-messi-fr.com legendary Argentine footballer, announced his transfer to the American club Inter Miami.

  67. PeterShilm says:

    Latest news on the Vinicius Junior fan site https://vinisius-junior.com. Vinicius Junior has been playing since 2018 for Real Madrid (Real Madrid). He plays in the Left Winger position.

  68. Everettvak says:

    Прокат и аренда автомобилей https://autorent.by в Минске 2019-2022. Сутки от 35 руб.

  69. ScottBrede says:

    Find the latest information on Khabib Nurmagomedov https://khabib-nurmagomedov.uz news and fights. Check out articles and videos detailing Khabib UFC career, interviews, wins, and biography.

  70. Discover how Riyad Mahrez https://al-ahli.riyad-mahrez.com transformed Al-Ahli, becoming a key player and catalyst in reaching new heights in world football.

  71. Davidles says:

    Get to know the history, players and latest news of the Inter Miami football club https://inter-miami.uz. Join us to learn about the successes and great performances of America’s newest and most exciting soccer club.

  72. Jorgejaf says:

    The latest top football news https://futebol-ao-vivo.net today. Interviews with football players, online broadcasts and match results, analytics and football forecasts

  73. Jimmymet says:

    Welcome to our official website, where you will find everything about the career of Gianluigi Buffon https://gianluigi-buffon.org. Discover the story of this legendary goalkeeper who made football history.

  74. JesseBip says:

    Gavi’s success story https://barcelona.gavi-fr.com at Barcelona: from his debut at 16 to a key role in club and national team of Spain, his talent inspires the world of football.

  75. WilliamFub says:

    Discover Pierre Gasly’s https://alpine.pierre-gasly.com journey through the world of Formula 1, from his beginnings with Toro Rosso to his extraordinary achievements with Alpine.

  76. Jamesthomo says:

    From childhood teams to championship victories, the path to success with the Los Angeles Lakers https://los-angeles-lakers.lebron-james-fr.com requires not only talent, but also undeniable dedication and work.

  77. Rodgertuh says:

    The story of the Moroccan footballer https://al-hilal.yassine-bounou.com, who became a star at Al-Hilal, traces his journey from the streets of Casablanca to international football stardom and his personal development.

  78. Neymar https://al-hilal.neymar-fr.com at Al-Hilal: his professionalism and talent inspire young people players, taking the club to new heights in Asian football.

  79. Thomastab says:

    Del Mar Energy Inc is an international industrial holding company engaged in the extraction of oil, gas, and coal

  80. BruceHop says:

    The story of the great Kobe Bryant https://los-angeles-lakers.kobe-bryant-fr.com with ” Los Angeles Lakers: his path to the championship, his legendary achievements.

  81. Claudemip says:

    Find out the story of Jon Jones https://ufc.jon-jones-fr.biz in the UFC: his triumphs, records and controversies, which made him one of the greatest fighters in the MMA world.

  82. Randydic says:

    Carlos Alcaraz https://tennis.carlos-alcaraz-fr.biz from a talented junior to the ATP top 10. His rise is the result of hard work, support and impressive victories at major world tournaments.

  83. Dennysah says:

    The fascinating story of Daniil Medvedev’s https://tennis.daniil-medvedev-fr.biz rise to world number one. Find out how a Russian tennis player quickly broke into the elite and conquered the tennis Olympus.

  84. CarlosSot says:

    The fascinating story of Alexander Zverev’s https://tennis.alexander-zverev-fr.biz rapid rise from a junior star to one of the leaders of modern tennis.

  85. Max Verstappen and Red Bull Racing’s https://red-bull-racing.max-verstappen-fr.com path to success in Formula 1. A story of talent, determination and team support leading to a championship title.

  86. JimmyMog says:

    Olympique de Marseille https://liga1.marseilles-fr.com after several years in the shadows, once again becomes champion of France. How did they do it and what prospects open up for the club

  87. A fascinating story about how Elon Musk https://spacex.elon-musk-fr.com and his company SpaceX revolutionized space exploration, opening new horizons for humanity.

  88. An exploration of Nicole Kidman’s https://watch.nicole-kidman-fr.com career, her notable roles, and her continued quest for excellence as an actress.

  89. Explore the rich history and unrivaled atmosphere of the iconic Old Trafford Stadium https://old-trafford.manchester-united-fr.com, home of one of the world’s most decorated football clubs, Manchester United.

  90. MatthewDop says:

    Tyson Fury https://wbc.tyson-fury-fr.com is the undefeated WBC world champion and reigns supreme in boxing’s heavyweight division.

  91. The story of Kanye West https://the-college-dropout.kanye-west-fr.com, starting with his debut album “The College Dropout,” which changed hip-hop and became his cultural legacy.

  92. The fascinating story of the phenomenal rise and meteoric fall of Diego Maradona https://napoli.diegomaradona.biz, who became a cult figure at Napoli in the 1980s.

  93. Cristiano Ronaldo https://al-nassr.cristianoronaldo-br.net one of the greatest football players of all time, begins a new chapter in his career by joining An Nasr Club.

  94. Stevenrem says:

    The story of Luka Modric’s rise https://real-madrid.lukamodric-br.com from young talent to one of the greatest midfielders of his generation and a key player for the Royals.

  95. From academy product to captain and leader of Real Madrid https://real-madrid.ikercasillas-br.com Casillas became one of the greatest players in the history of Real Madrid.

  96. Follow Bernardo Silva’s impressive career https://manchester-city.bernardosilva.net from his debut at Monaco to to his status as a key player and leader of Manchester City.

  97. Хотите научиться готовить самые изысканные и сложные торты? В этом https://v1.skladchik.org/tags/tort/ разделе вы найдете множество подробных пошаговых рецептов самых трендовых и известных тортов с возможностью получить их за сущие копейки благодаря складчине. Готовьте с удовольствием и открывайте для себя новые рецепты вместе с Skladchik.org

  98. Chuckhat says:

    Лучшие пансионаты для пожилых людей https://ernst-neizvestniy.ru в Самаре – недорогие дома для престарелых в Самарской области

  99. The fascinating story of Sergio Ramos’ https://seville.sergioramos.net rise from Sevilla graduate to one of Real Madrid and Spain’s greatest defenders.

  100. JesusWough says:

    Ousmane Dembele’s https://paris-saint-germain.ousmanedembele-br.com rise from promising talent to key player for French football giants Paris Saint-Germain. An exciting success story.

  101. DonaldRon says:

    The compelling story of Alisson Becker’s https://bayer-04.florianwirtz-br.com meteoric rise from young talent to key figure in Liverpool’s triumphant era under Jurgen Klopp.

  102. O meio-campista Rafael Veiga leva https://palmeiras.raphaelveiga-br.com o Palmeiras ao sucesso – o campeonato brasileiro e a vitoria na Copa Libertadores aos 24 anos.

  103. The rise of 20-year-old midfielder Jamal Musiala https://bavaria.jamalmusiala-br.com to the status of a winger in the Bayern Munich team. A story of incredible talent.

  104. Williamrob says:

    In-depth articles about the most famous football players https://zenit-saint-petersburg.wendel-br.com, clubs and events. Learn everything about tactics, rules of the game and football history.

  105. Michaelmus says:

    Ayrton Senna https://mclaren.ayrtonsenna-br.com is one of the greatest drivers in the history of Formula 1.

  106. Anderson Silva https://killer-bees-muay-thai-college.andersonsilva.net was born in 1975 in Curitiba Brazil. From a young age he showed an interest in martial arts, starting to train in karate at the age of 5.

  107. HerbertHah says:

    Bruno Miguel Borges Fernandes https://manchester-united.brunofernandes-br.com was born on September 8, 1994 in Maia, Portugal.

  108. TravisCig says:

    Earvin “Magic” Johnson https://los-angeles-lakers.magicjohnson.biz is one of the most legendary basketball players in history. NBA history.

  109. Stacyalelt says:

    Victor Osimhen https://napoli.victorosimhen-ar.com born on December 29, 1998 in Lagos, Nigeria, has grown from an initially humble player to one of the brightest strikers in modern football.

  110. Toni Kroos https://real-madrid.tonikroos-ar.com the German midfielder known for his accurate passes and calmness on the field, has achieved remarkable success at one of the most prestigious football clubs in the world.

  111. Jasonkag says:

    Robert Lewandowski https://barcelona.robertlewandowski-ar.com is one of the most prominent footballers of our time, and his move to Barcelona has become one of the most talked about topics in world football.

  112. Pablostori says:

    Pedro Gonzalez Lopez https://barcelona.pedri-ar.com known as Pedri, was born on November 25, 2002 in the small town of Tegeste, located on Tenerife, one of the Canary Islands.

  113. The story of Leo Messi https://inter-miami.lionelmessi.ae‘s transfer to Inter Miami began long before the official announcement. Rumors about Messi’s possible departure from Barcelona appeared in 2020

  114. Robertcok says:

    Andreson Souza Conceicao https://al-nassr.talisca-ar.com known as Talisca, is one of the brightest stars of modern football.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News Of This Category
https://slotbet.online/